Article
Impacto de múltiplas biópsias em dois pontos distintos da superfície pleural no diagnóstico de tuberculose
Impact of multiple biopsies in two different sites of the pleural surface for the diagnosis of tuberculosis
Registro en:
CHALOUB, M. et al. Impacto de múltiplas biópsias em dois pontos distintos da superfície pleural no diagnóstico de tuberculose. Jornal de Pneumologia, v. 26, n. 2, p. 55-60, 2000.
0102-3586
dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0102-35862000000200003
Autor
Chaloub, Marcelo
Fodelis, Ronald
Barreto, Ana Paula
Ramos, Eduardo Antônio Gonçalves
Barral Netto, Manoel
Barbosa Junior, Aryon de Almeida
Resumen
Com o objetivo de avaliar se a retirada de maior número de fragmentos pleurais em um único sítio (A),
bem como se a biópsia em um segundo sítio (B) da sua superfície, através do mesmo orifício cutâneo,
acrescenta em rendimento diagnóstico aos três fragmentos habitualmente retirados, conduzimos um
estudo prospectivo no Hospital Octávio Mangabeira, envolvendo 115 pacientes com indicação de
biópsia pleural. Os fragmentos pleurais foram colocados em três frascos distintos: FRA1-3 = 3 primeiros
fragmentos, FRA4-8 = 5 fragmentos subseqüentes e FRB1-5 = 5 fragmentos em segundo sítio da
superfície pleural. Era retirada a agulha até o subcutâneo, feitas inclinação lateral e reintrodução no
espaço pleural. A análise dos fragmentos provindos do FRA1-3 evidenciou granuloma em 72/92 casos
de tuberculose (78,3%) e no FRA4-8 e FRB1-5, em 74/92 casos (80,5%). Em 6/92 pacientes foram
encontrados pleurite inespecífica no FRA1-3 e granuloma no FRA4-8, resultando em acréscimo diagnóstico
de 8,3% (6 aos 72 pacientes). Em 7/92 pacientes (7,6%) a HP foi inespecífica no sítio A e mostrou
granuloma no sítio B, resultando em acréscimo diagnóstico de 9,0% (7 aos 78 pacientes). A
concordância histológica intra-observador teve um índice kappa de 0,62 (0,54 a 0,70) e
interobservador de 0,64 (0,56 a 0,72). Concluímos que a realização de múltiplas biópsias em dois
sítios diferentes da superfície pleural diagnosticou 13 pacientes que não obteriam diagnóstico definitivo
se fossem retirados apenas três fragmentos pleurais, resultando em incremento diagnóstico de 18,0%
(13 aos 72 diagnosticados no FRA1-3), sendo considerado significativo do ponto de vista médico e social. For diagnostic purposes of pleural tuberculosis, three pleural fragments are routinely obtained
from a single site by needle biopsy. The objective of this study is to compare the diagnostic yield
of the routine procedure with two different approaches: harvesting five fragments on a single site
(A), and collection of fragments at an additional site (B); from the same cutaneous orifice, the
needle was partially removed up to the subcutaneous tissue and redirected at a 45o angle. The
authors performed a prospective study in 115 patients submitted to pleural biopsy. The first three
pleural fragments were placed in a vial (VA1-3), the 5 subsequent fragments obtained at the same
site were placed in a second vial (VA4-8), and the five fragments from the second site were placed in
a third vial (VB1-5). Analysis of fragments from VA1-3 revealed granuloma in 72/92 tuberculosis cases
(78.3%), whereas in fragments VA5-8 and VB1-5, granuloma was observed in 74/92 cases (80.5%). In
6/92 patients the diagnosis at VA1-3 was non-specific pleuritis, but granuloma was found in VA4-8,
resulting in a diagnosis increment of 8.3% (adding six to the 72 patients). In 7/92 patients (7.6%)
the histopathological examination at site A led to a non-specific result but granuloma was found at site B, leading to a diagnostic increment of 9.0% (7 to 78 patients). Histological concordance of
two examinations by the same pathologist had a kappa index of 0.62 (0.54 to 0.7) whereas
concordance between two different pathologists had a kappa index of 0.64 (0.56 to 0.72). The
performance of multiple biopsies at two different sites at the pleural surface led to an additional
diagnosis of 13 patients, i.e., an increase of 18% (13 to 72) relative to the routine procedure.
Considering the low cost increase of obtaining the fragments, adoption of this method is
recommended in routine pleural tuberculosis diagnosis.