Actas de congresos
The Persistence Of The Theory Of Indigenous Degeneration And Colonialism Within The Theoretical Foundations Of Brazilian Archeology [a Persistência Da Teoria Da Degeneração Indígena E Do Colonialismo Nos Fundamentos Da Arqueologia Brasileira]
Registro en:
Historia, Ciencias, Saude - Manguinhos. , v. 14, n. 4, p. 1239 - 1264, 2007.
1045970
2-s2.0-38049101308
Autor
Noelli F.S.
Ferreira L.M.
Institución
Resumen
The article examines the persistence of certain theoretical foundations of Brazilian archeology and Americanist thought. The theory of indigenous degeneration and the colonialist argument display a secular continuity characterized by common political and thematic lines. This is analyzed through a comparison of some of the topics addressed in the works of seminal figures like Karl Friedrich Philipp von Martius, Francisco Adolfo de Varnhagen, and Betty Jane Meggers. 14 4 1239 1264 Arboleda, Luis Carlos 2000 A ciência e o ideal de ascensão social dos crioulos no vice-reinado de Nova Granada. In: Figueirôa, Silvia F. de M (Org.). Um olhar sobre o passado: história das ciências na América Latina. São Paulo: Imprensa Oficial Ed. Unicamp. p.121-152Bandinelli, R.B., (1984) L'arte classica: Arte greca, ritrato, , Roma: Riuniti Bhabha, H.K., (1995) The location of culture, , London: Routledge (1990) Nation and narration, , Bhabha, Homi K, Ed, London: Routledge Blanckaert, C., Buffon and the natural history of man: Writing history and the 'foundational myth' of anthropology (1993) History of Human Sciences, 6 (1), pp. 13-50. , Durham UK, v Bohemer, E., (1995) Colonial and postcolonial literature, , Oxford: Oxford University Press Bravo, M.T., Ethnological encounters (1997) Cultures of natural history, pp. 338-357. , Jardine, Nicholas Secord, James Spary, Emma C Ed, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. p Brydon, D., Internal colonialisms and subaltern studies (2000) Postcolonialism: Critical concepts in literary and cultural studies, pp. 1345-1568. , Brydon, Diana Ed, London: Routledge. p Canguilhem, G., (1989) Études d'histoire et de philosophie des ciences, , Paris: Librairie Phipolosophique J. Vrin Canguilhem, G., (1979) Le normal et le pathologique, , Paris: PUF Champion, T.C., Medieval archaeology and the tyranny of the historical record (1990) From the Baltic to the Black Sea, pp. 79-95. , Austin, David Alcock, Leslie Ed, London: Unwin Hyman. p Chatterje, P., (1993) The nation and its fragments: Colonial and postcolonial histories, , Princeton: Princeton University Press Delle, James A. Sept. 2003 On collaboration, class conflict, and archaeology in Brazil. International Journal of Historical Archaeology, New York, v.7, n.3, p.223-237Díaz-Andreu, M., Britain and the other: The archaeology of imperialism (2003) History, identity and the question of Britain, pp. 2-10. , Phillips, Rob Brocklehurst, Helen Ed, New York: Palgrave. p Ferreira, L.M., Footsteps of american race: Archaeology, ethnography and romanticism in imperial Brazil (2005) Global archaeology theory: Contextual voices and contemporary thoughts, pp. 135-156. , Funari, Pedro Paulo A, Zarankin, Andrés Stovel, Emily Ed, New York: Springer. p Ferreira, L.M., Gonçalves Dias: Arqueólogo e etnógrafo (2003) Lopes, Marcos Antônio (Org.) Grandes nomes da história intelectual, pp. 456-464. , São Paulo: Contexto. p Fonseca, Maria Raquel de G. Fróes Da 1996 A única ciência é a pátria: o discurso científico na construção do Brasil e do México (1770-1815). Tese (Doutoramento) - Faculdade de Filosofia, Letras e Ciências Humanas, Universidade de São Paulo, São PauloFunari, Pedro Paulo A. 2003 Class interests in brazilian archaeology. International Journal of Historical Archaeology, New York, v.6, n.3, p.209-216Funari, P.P.A., Mixed features of archaeological theory in Brazil (1995) Theory in archaeology: A world perspective, pp. 237-250. , Ucko, Peter Ed, London: Routledge. p Funari, Pedro Paulo A. 1991 Archaeology in Brazil: politics and scholarship at a crossroads. World Archaeological Bulletin, Southampton, v.5, p.123-132Goldberg, D.T., The racial rule (1999) Relocating postcolonialism, pp. 82-102. , Goldberg, David T, Quayson, Ato, Oxford: Blackwell. p Gosden, C., (2002) Anthropology and archaeology, , London: Routledge Gould, S.J., (1981) The mismeasure of man, , New York: W.W. Norton Hall, M., (2000) Archaeology and the modern world: Colonial transcripts in South Africa and the Chesapeake, , London: Routledge Hall, S., When was the postcolonial? (1996) The post-colonial question: Common skies, divided horizons, pp. 242-260. , Chambers, Iain Curti, Lidia Balzano, Wanda Ed, London: Routledge. p Hinsley, C.M., (1981) The Smithsonian Institution and the american indian: Making anthropology in Victorian America, , Washington: Smithsonian Institution Press Horsman, R., (1981) Race and manifest destiny, , Cambridge: Harvard University Press Kipling, R., (1901) Kim, , London: McMillan Loomba, A., (2000) Colonialism/postcolonialism, , London: Routledge MacGuire, R., (1992) A marxist archaeology, , San Diego: Academic Press MacLeod, R., On visiting the moving metropolis: Reflections on the architecture of imperial science (1996) Scientific aspects of european expansion, pp. 23-55. , Storey, William K, Ed, Hampshire: Variorum. p Magalhães, (1876) José Vieira Couto de 1935 O selvagem, , 2.ed. Rio de Janeiro: Cia. Ed. Nacional. 1.ed Magalhães, José Vieira Couto de 1875 Memória sobre as colônias militares, nacionais e indígenas. Rio de Janeiro: Tipografia da ReformaMalthus, Thomas R. 1967 An essay on the principle of population. London: Everyman's. 1.ed., 1798Martius, (1831) Karl Friedrich Philipp von 1992 Frey Apollonio: Um romance do, , Brasil. São Paulo: Brasiliense. 1.ed Martius, Karl Friedrich Philipp von 1907 O Estado de direito entre os autóctones do Brasil (1832) Revista do Instituto Histórico e Geográfico de São Paulo, 11, pp. 20-82. , São Paulo, v, 1.ed Martius, Karl Friedrich Philipp von 1905 Etnografia americana: O passado e o futuro do homem americano (1838) Revista do Instituto Histórico e Geográfico de São Paulo, 9, pp. 534-562. , São Paulo, v, 1.ed Martius, Karl Friedrich Philipp von 1844 Como se deve escrever a história do Brasil. Revista do Instituto Histórico e Geográfico Brasileiro, Rio de Janeiro, v.6, p.389-411Meggers, Betty J. 2001 The continuing quest for El Dorado: round two. Latin American Antiquity, Washington, v.12, n.3, p.304-325Meggers, B.J., Desenvolvimento cultural pré- histórico nas terras baixas tropicais da América do Sul: Amazonas e Orinoco (1999) Fronteiras, Campo Grande, 2 (4), pp. 9-38 Meggers, B.J., O paraíso ilusório revisitado (1998) Revista do Museu de Arqueologia e Etnologia, 8, pp. 33-55. , São Paulo, v Meggers, B.J., Jomon-Valdivia similaties: Convergence or contact? (1998) Across before Columbus, pp. 10-21. , Gilmore, Donald Y, McElroy, Linda S, Ed, Edgecomb: Neara. p Meggers, B.J., La Amazonía en vísperas del contacto europeo: Perspectivas etnohistóricas, ecológicas y antropológicas (1997) Arqueología, antropología y historia en los Andes: Homenaje a María Rostworowski, pp. 93-113. , Gabai, Rafael Varón Espinoza, Javier Flores Ed, Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos. p Meggers, B.J., La cerámica temprana en América del Sur: ¿invención independiente o difusión? (1997) Revista de Arqueología Americana, (13), pp. 7-40. , México D.F Meggers, B.J., (1996) Amazonia: Man in a counterfeit paradise, , 2.ed. Washington: Smithsonian Institution Press Meggers, Betty J. 1996b Possible impact of the Mega-Niño events precolumbian population in the Caribbean Area. In: Maggiolo, Marcio V. Fuentes, Angel C. (Ed.). Primer Seminário de Arqueología del Caribe. Altos de Chavón: Museo Arqueológico Regional Altos de Chavón OEA. p.156-176Meggers, B.J., Judging the future by the past: The impact of environmental instability on prehistoric amazonian populations (1995) Indigenous peoples and the future of Amazonia: An ecological anthropology and endangered world, pp. 15-43. , Sponsel, Leslie A, Ed, Tucson: University of Arizona Press. p Meggers, B.J., Archaeological evidence for the impact of mega-Niño events on Amazonia during the past two millennia (1994) Climatic Change, 28 (2), pp. 321-338 Meggers, B.J., Biogeographical approaches to reconstructing the prehistory of Amazonia (1994) Biogeographica, 70 (3), pp. 97-110. , Paris, v Meggers, B.J., Prehistoric population density in the Amazon basin (1992) Disease and demography in the Americas, pp. 197-205. , Verano, John W, Ubelacker, Douglas H, Ed, Washington: Smithsonian Institution Press. p Meggers, B.J., El significado de la difusión como factor de evolución (1985) Chungará, (14), pp. 81-90. , Arica Meggers, B.J., (1979) América pré- histórica, , Rio de Janeiro: Paz e Terra Meggers, B.J., Climatic oscillation as a factor in the prehistory of Amazonia (1979) American Antiquity, 44 (2), pp. 252-266. , Washington, v Meggers, B.J., (1977) Amazônia: A ilusão de um paraíso, , Rio de Janeiro: Civilização Brasileira Meggers, B.J., Vegetational fluctuation and prehistoric cultural adaptation in Amazonia: Some tentative correlations (1977) World Archaeology, 8, pp. 287-302. , London, v Meggers, B.J., Application of the biological model of diversification to cultural distributions in tropical lowland South America (1975) Biotropica, (7), pp. 141-161. , Zurich Meggers, B.J., The transpacific origins of mesoamerican civilization: A preliminary review of the evidence and the theoretical implications (1975) American Anthropologist, 77 (1), pp. 1-27. , Irvine, v Meggers, B.J., (1971) Amazonia: Man and culture in a counterfeit paradise, , Chicago: Aldine Meggers, Betty J. 1958 Ambiente y cultura en la cuenca del Amazonas: revisión de la teoría del determinismo ambiental. Estudíos sobre ecología humana: conferencias celebradass en la Sociedad de Antropología de Washington. Washington: Unión PanamericanaMeggers, B.J., Environmental limitation on the development of culture (1954) American Anthropologist, 56 (3), pp. 801-824. , Irvine, v Meggers, B.J., Danon, J., Identification and implications of a hiatus in the archeological sequence on Marajó Island, Brazil (1988) Journal of the Washington Academy of Sciences, 78 (3), pp. 245-253. , Arlington, v Meggers, B.J., Implications of archaeological distributions in Amazonia (1988) Proceedings of a workshop on neotropical distributional patterns, pp. 275-294. , Heyer, W. Ronald Vanzolini, Paulo E, Ed, Rio de Janeiro: Academia Brasileira de Ciências. p Meggers, B.J., Evans, C., Lowland South America and Antilles (1978) Ancient native americans, pp. 543-591. , Jennings, Jesse D, Ed, San Francisco: W.H. Freeman. p Meggers, Betty J. Evans, Clifford 1973 A reconstituição da pré-história amazônica: algumas consideraç ões teóricas. Belém: Museu Paraense Emílio Goeldi (Publicações Avulsas, 20). p.51-69Meggers, B.J., Evans, C., (1957) Archaeological investigations at the Mouth of the Amazon, , Washington: Smithsonian Institution Press Meggers, B.J., Miller, E.T., Hunter-gatherers in Amazonia during the Pleistocene-Holocene transition (2003) Under the Canopy: The archeology of tropical rain forests, pp. 291-316. , Mercader, J, Ed, New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press. p Mellati, J.C., (1970) Índios do Brasil, , Brasília: Coordenada Meskell, L., Introduction: Archaeological matters (1998) Archaeology under fire: Nationalism, politics and heritage in the Eastern Mediterranean and Middle Eastern, pp. 1-12. , Meskell, Lynn Ed, London: Routledge. p Noelli, F.S., The Tupi: Explaining origin and expansion in terms of archaeology and historical linguistics (1998) Antiquity, 72 (277), pp. 648-663. , Cambridge, v Noelli, F.S., As hipóteses sobre o centro de origem e as rotas de expansão dos Tupi (1996) Revista de Antropologia, 39 (2), pp. 7-53. , São Paulo, v Oliveira, Jorge E. de 2002 A arqueologia brasileira da década de 1980 ao início do século XXI: uma avaliação histórica e historiográfica. Estudos Ibero-Americanos, Porto Alegre, v.28, n.2, p.25-52Orwell, G., (2005) Dentro da baleia e outros ensaios, , São Paulo: Companhia das Letras Pastrana, P.E.A., La difusión de la ciencia en la Nueva España: La polémica en torno de la nomenclatura de Linneo y Lavoisier (1987) Quipu, 3 (4), pp. 387-403. , México DF, v Patterson, T.C., (2001) A social history of anthropology in the United States, , Oxford: Berg Pena, Domingos Soares Ferreira 1877 Apontamentos sobre os cerâmios do Pará. Arquivos do Museu Nacional, Rio de Janeiro, v.2, p.47-76Pena, Domingos Soares Ferreira 1876 Breve notícia sobre os Sambaquis do Pará. Arquivos do Museu Nacional, Rio de Janeiro, v.1, p.85-89Petitjean, P., Sciences et empires: Un thème promèteur, des enjeux cruciaux (1992) Science and empires: Historical studies about scientific development and european expansion, pp. 3-13. , Petitjean, Patrick Jami, Catherine Moulin, Anne-Marie Ed, Dordrecht: Kluver Academics Publishers. p Prakash, G., Introduction: After colonialism (1995) After colonialism: Imperial histories and postcolonial displacements, , Prakash, Gyan, Princeton: Princeton University Press Quayson, A., (2000) Postcolonialism: Theory, practice or process, , Oxford: Oxford University Press Ribeiro, D., (1970) Os índios e a civilização: A integração das populações indígenas no Brasil moderno, , Rio de Janeiro: Civilização Brasileira Rodrigues, J.B., Antigüidades do Amazonas (1876) Ensaios de Ciência, 1, pp. 93-125. , Rio de Janeiro, v Rodrigues, J.B., Antigüidades do Amazonas: A arte cerâmica (1876) Ensaios de Ciência, 2, pp. 3-23. , Rio de Janeiro, v Roosevelt, A.C., (1991) Moundbuilders of the Amazon: Geophysical archaeology on Marajó Island, , Brazil. San Diego: San Diego Academic Press Rueda, C.H.L., (2003) Arqueología colombiana: Ciencia, pasado y exclusión, , Bogotá: Colciencias Said, E., Secular interpretation, the geographical element, and the methodology of imperialism (1995) After colonialism: Imperial histories and postcolonial displacement, pp. 21-39. , Prakash, Gyan, Princeton: Princeton University Press. p Said, E., Representing the colonized: Anthropology's interlocutors (1989) Critical Inquiry, 15 (2), pp. 205-225. , Chicago, v Saldaña, J.J., Marcos conceptuales de la historia de las ciencias en Latinoamérica: Positivismo e economicismo (1986) Quipu, 1, pp. 57-79. , México D.F, v Sánchez, R.N., (2004) El pasado con intención: Hacía una reconstrucción del pensamiento arqueológico en Venezuela, , Caracas: Facultad de Ciencias Económicas y Sociales Steward, J.H., South American cultures: An interpretative summary (1949) Handbook of south american indians, 5, pp. 669-772. , Steward, Julian H, Ed, Washington: Smithsonian Institution. p Steward, J.H., The native population of South America (1949) Handbook of south american indians, 5, pp. 655-668. , Steward, Julian H, Ed, Washington: Smithsonian Institution. p Steward, J.H., Cultural causality and law: A trial formulation of the development of early civilizations (1949) American Anthropologist, 51 (1), pp. 1-27. , Irvine, v Steward, J.H., Culture areas of the tropical forests (1948) Handbook of south american indians, 3, pp. 883-899. , Steward, Julian H, Ed, Washington: Smithsonian Institution. p Steward, J.H., Tribes of the Montana: An introduction (1948) Handbook of south american indians, 3, pp. 507-533. , Steward, Julian H, Ed, Washington: Smithsonian Institution. p Steward, J.H., Faron, L.C., (1959) Native peoples of South America, , New York: McGraw-Hill Trigger, B.G., (1990) A history of archaeological thought, , Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Varnhagen, (1854) Francisco Adolfo de 1975 História Geral do, , Brasil. 9.ed. São Paulo: Melhoramentos. 1.ed Varnhagen, Francisco Adolfo de 15 jul. 1851 Memória sobre os trabalhos que se podem consultar nas negociações dos limites do Império, com algumas lembranças para a demarcação deste escrita por ordem do Ex. Sr. Conselheiro José Paulino Soares de Souza, Ministro e Secretário de Estado dos Negócios Estrangeiros. Rio de Janeiro. Lata 340, pasta 6 (Instituto Histórico e Geográfico Brasileiro)Varnhagen, Francisco Adolfo de 1849 Etnografia indígena: línguas, emigrações e arqueologia - padrão de mármore dos primeiros descobridores. Revista do Instituto Histórico e Geográfico Brasileiro, Rio de Janeiro, v.11, p.366-376Varnhagen, Francisco Adolfo de 1841 Sobre a necessidade do estudo e ensino das línguas indígenas do Brasil. Revista do Instituto Histórico e Geográfico Brasileiro, Rio de Janeiro, v.3, p.53-63Veigt, U., Ethnic concepts in german prehistory: A case study on the relationship between cultural identity and archaeological objectivity (1989) Archaeological approaches to cultural identity, pp. 45-82. , Shennan, Stephen Ed, London: Unwin Hyman. p Young, R.J.C., (2001) Postcolonialism: An historical introduction, , Oxford: Blackwell