Artículos de revistas
Representativeness And Innovation In The Management Of The Participatory Processes: The Case Of The Brazilian Organizations Of Family Farmers [representatividade E Inovação Na Governança Dos Processos Participativos: O Caso Das Organizações Brasileiras De Agricultores Familiares]
Registro en:
Sociologias. , v. , n. 24, p. 268 - 306, 2010.
15174522
2-s2.0-77956523710
Autor
Abramovay R.
Magalhaes R.
schroder M.
Institución
Resumen
Territorial development involves the organized participation of social actors in decisions regarding the use of the public - and, largely, private - resources of a region. Despite the obvious democratic virtues of the participatory processes, there has been a recent increase in the critical literature, questioning their results. This paper intends to reveal the tension experienced by the contemporary social movements: the conflict between representativeness and innovation. Representative movements tend to consolidate and strengthen interests, and their institutionalization pushes them towards routine attitudes that often block their innovative potential. One way out of the impasses of the social movements is in the terms of management of the social participation focused explicitly on learning and innovation. Organizations coming from social movements are an essential part of the participatory processes. This article, based on the example of the Brazilian policy of strengthening family agriculture, examines two of those organizations whose origin is in the social movements: the Federação dos Trabalhadores na Agricultura Familiar - FETRAF (Federation of Workers in Family Farming), which is a trade union; and the CRESOL System of cooperatives for credit outreach. Both organizations stimulate participatory processes and are associated with government policies. In the case of the trade union, however, social participation does not result in innovation, and the ties with the government tend to restrict the movement to relations already known. As regards the credit cooperative, social participation and ties with the government are the result of incentives that encourage the strengthening of what the new economic sociology calls weak ties, and thus open the way to expand the very foundations of the processes of local development.
24 268 306 Abramovay, R., Veiga, J.E., (1999) Novas instituições para o desenvolvimento rural: O caso do Programa Nacional de Fortalecimento da Agricultura Familiar (PRONAF), , Brasília : FIPE/IPEA Abramovay, R., Magalhães, R., Schröder, M., La agricultura familiar em el sur de Brasil: Entre sector y território (2007) Territorios rurales: Movimientos sociales y desarrollo territorial rural en América Latina, pp. 316-356. , Desarrollo territorial rural. BENGOA, José (Ed.) Santiago: RIMISP/Catalonia Acemoglu, D., Robinson, J.A., (2005) Economic Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy, , Cambridge (UK): Cambridge University Press Aghion, B.A., Morduch, J., (2005) The Economics of Microfinance, , Cambridge (MA): The MIT Press Bagnasco, A., Trigilia, C., (1988) La construction sociale du marché: Ledéfi de la troisième Italie, , Cachan: Les Éditions de l'Ecole Normale Supérieure de Cachan. 1993 Boschi, R.R., Descentralização, Clientelismo e Capital Social na Governança Urbana: Comparando Belo Horizonte e Salvador (1999) Dados, 42 (4). , Rio de Janeiro Bourdieu, P., Principles of an Economic Anthropology (2005) The Handbook of Economic Sociology, pp. 75-89. , Smelser, Neil Swedberg, Richard (Eds.). Second Edition. Princeton: Princeton University Press Chambers, R., The origins and practice of participatory rural appraisal (1994) World Development, 22 (7), pp. 953-969 Chambers, R., (1997) Whose Reality Counts? Putting the First Last, , London: Intermediate Technology Publications Coelho, V.S., Brazilian Health Councils: Including the excluded? (2006) Spaces for Change? The Politics of Participation in New Democratic Arenas, , Cornawall, A. Coelho, V. London: Zed Books. Forthcoming Cooke, B., The Social Psychological Limits of Participation? (2001) Participation: The New Tyranny?, pp. 102-121. , Cook, Bill Kothari, Uma. London, New York: Zed Books Cooke, B., Kothari, U., (2001) Participation: The New Tiranny?, , London, New York: Zed Books, 2004 Cortes, S.M.V., Fóruns participativos e governança: Uma sistematização das contribuições da literatura (2005) Desenho institucional e participação política - Experiências no Brasil contemporâneo, pp. 13-32. , Lubambo, Catia Coêlho, Denílson B. Melo, Marcus A. (Orgs). Petrópolis: Vozes De Ferranti, D., (2003) Inequality in Latin America and the Caribbean: Breaking with History?, , World Bank Latin American and Caribbean Studies, Advance Conference Edition: The World Bank, Washington Evans, P., Development as Institutional Change: The Pitfalls of Monocropping and the Potentials of Deliberation (2004) Studies in Comparative International Development, 38 (4), pp. 30-52. , Winter Fligstein, N., Social skill and the theory of fields (2001) Sociological Theory, 19 (2), pp. 105-125 Fligstein, N., (2001) The Architecture of markets: An Economic Sociology of twenty-first-century capitalist societies, , Princeton University Press Fujita, M., Thisse, J.F., Agglomération et marché (2001) Cahiers d'Economie et Sociologie Rurales, pp. 11-57 Fung, A., Olin Wright, E., (2003) Deepening Democracy - Institutional Innovations in Empowered Participatory Governance, , The Real Utopias Project. Londres: Verso Goldstone, J., More social movements or fewer? Beyond political opportunity structures to relational fields (2004) Theory and Society, 33, pp. 333-365 Granovetter, M., (1974) Getting a Job - A Study of Contacts and Careers, , Chicago: Chicago University Press, 1995 Da Silva Graziano, J., Del Grossi, M., Rural nonfarm employment and incomes in Brazil: Patterns and evolution (2001) World Development, 29 (3), pp. 443-453 Habermas, J., (1989) Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere, , Cambridge: MIT Press Hirschman, A., (1970) Exit, voice and loyalty - Responses to Decline in Firms, organization and States, , Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press Hoffman, A., (2001) From Heresy to Dogma-an Institutional History of Corporate Environmentalism, , Stanford (CA): Stanford University Press Hommel, T., (2004) Stratégies des firmes industrielles et contestation sociale, , Paris: CEMAGREF, CIRAD, IFREMER, INRA Jacobi, P., A gestão participativa de bacias hidrográficas no Brasil e os desafios do fortalecimento de espaços colegiados (2004) Participação e Deliberação - Teoria democrática e experiências institucionais no Brasil contemporâneo, 34, pp. 270-289. , Nobre, M. Schattan, V. (Orgs.). São Paulo: Editora Jobert, A., Le dialogue social territorial: Cadres nationaux et diversités territoriales (2006) Les Cinquièmes Journées de la Proximité La proximité, entre interactions et institutions, , http://beagle.u-bordeaux4.fr/conf2006/viewpaper.php?id=74&print=1#_ftnref1, GRES, Bordeaux, 28-30 Juin. Acessado em 12/03/2007 Krugman, P., (1995) Development, Geography and Economic Geography, , Cambridge (MA): The MIT Press Lin, N., (2001) Social Capital - A Theory of Social Structure and Action, , Cambridge (UK): Cambridge University Press Mainwaring, S., (1986) The Catholic Church and Politics in Brazil - 1916-1985, , Stanford (CA): Stanford University Press Mansuri, G., Rao, V., Community-based and -driven development: A critical review (2004) The World Bank Research Observer, 19 (1), pp. 1-39 Mohan, G., Stokke, K., Participatory development and empowerment: The dangers of localism (2000) Third World Quarterly, 21 (2), pp. 247-268 Morgan, K., Learning-by-interacting: Inter-firm Networks and Enterprise Support (1996) Networks of Enterprises and local development - Competing and Co-operating in Local Productive Systems, , OECD. LEED/OECD, Territorial Development, Paris, 1999 Mosse, D., "People's Knowledge", Participation and Patronage: Operations and Representations in Rural Development (2001) Participation: The New Tyranny?, pp. 16-35. , Cook, Bill Kothari, Uma. London, New York: Zed Books Moulaert, F., Nussbaumer, J., Beyond the learning region: The dialectics of innovation and culture in territorial development (2005) Learning from clusters - A Critical Assessment from an Economic-Geographical Perspective, pp. 89-110. , Boschma, Ron Kloosterman, Robert (Eds.). Doordrecht, The Netherlands. Springer Navarro, Z., Democracia e controle social de fundos públicos - o caso do 'orçamento participativo' de Porto Alegre (Brasil) (1999) O Público Não-Estatal na Reforma do Estado, , Bresser Prereira, Luiz Carlos GRAU, Nuria Cunill (Orgs.). Rio de Janeiro: Editora Fundação Getúlio Vargas Neveu, É., (1996) Sociologie des mouvements sociaux, , Paris: La Découverte. 2005 (2001) Cities and regions in the new learning economy, , OCDE. Paris (2001) Perspectives territoriales de l'OCDE, , OCDE. Paris (2005) Enforcing the Rule of Law: The Politics of Societal Accountability in Latin America, , Peruzzotti, Enrique Smulovitz, Catalina (Eds.). Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press Putnam, R., (1993) Making Democracy Work: Civic Tradition in Mondern Italy, , Princeton, Princeton University Press Pyke, F., Beccatini, G., Senclenberger, W., (1990) Industrial Districts and Interfirms Cooperation in Italy, , (orgs.) International Institute for Labour Studies, Ginebra Ribot, J.C., Peluso, N.L., A theory of access (2003) Rural Sociology, 68 (2), pp. 153-181 Rita, G., Bonomi, A., (1998) Manifesto per lo Sviluppo Locale - Dall'azione di comunità ai Patti territoriali, , Torino: Bollati Boringhieri Sabel, C., Learning by Monitoring: The Institutions of Economic Development (1994) The Handbook of Economic Sociology, pp. 137-165. , Smelser, Neil Swedberd, Richard (Eds.). Princeton: Princeton University Press Sabel, C., Beyond Principal-Agent Governance: Experimentalist Organizations, Learning and Accountability (2004) De Staat van de Democratie, pp. 173-195. , http://www2.law.columbia.edu/sabel/papers.htm, Engelen, Ewald Ho, Monika Sie Dhian (Eds.), Democratie voorbij de Staat. WRR Verkenning 3. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, Acessado em 21/06/2006 Sachs, I., Development and Ethics. Whither Latin America? National Development Strategies in the Globalization Age (2002) Paper prepared for the IDB meeting on Ethics and Development, , http://www.iadb.org/Etica/Documentos/ar2_sac_desar-i.pdf, Buenos Aires, September 5-6. Acessado em 12/03/2007 Schejtman, A., Berdegué, J., Desarrollo territorial rural (2007) Territorios rurales: Movimientos sociales y desarrollo territorial rural en América Latina, pp. 45-83. , Bengoa, José (Ed.) Santiago: RIMISP/Catalonia (2004) Local Enterprises in the Global Economy: Issues of Governance and Upgrading, , Schmitz, Hubert (Ed.). Cheltenhan. UK, Northampton (MA), USA. Edward Elgar Sen, A., (2000) Development as Freedom, , New York: Anchor Books Smulovitz, C., Peruzzotti, E., Societal accountability: The other side of control (2000) Journal of Democracy, 11 (4), pp. 147-158. , october Souza, C., Sistema brasileiro de governança local: Inovações institucionais e sustentabilidade (2005) Desenho institucional e participação política - Experiências no Brasil contemporâneo, pp. 108-130. , Lubambo, Catia Coêlho, Denílson B. Melo, Marcus A. (Orgs.). Petrópolis: Vozes Swedberg, R., (1998) Max Weber and the Idea of Economic Sociology, , Princeton, Princeton University Press Tarrow, S., (1998) Power in Movement - Social Movements and Contentious Politics, , Cambridge University Press, 2005 Tendler, J., Tendler, J., Why are Social Funds so Popular? (2000) Local Dynamics in an Era of Globalization: 21st Century Catalysts for Development, pp. 113-129. , Simon J. Evenett, Weiping Wu, Shahid Yusuf (Eds.). Oxford University Press, World Bank (1993) First World Interest Groups: A comparative perspective, , Thomas, Clive S. (Ed.). Westport: Greenwood Press Tilly, C., Social movements and (all sorts of) other political interactions - local, national, and international - including identities (1988) Theory and Society, 27 (4), pp. 453-480. , August Tordoir, P., Economic capabilities and strategic clusters: New perspectives for national and regional economic policy (2005) Learning from clusters - A Critical Assessment from an Economic-Geographical Perspective, pp. 367-387. , Boschma, Ron Kloosterman, Robert. (Eds.). Doordrecht, The Netherlands. Springer Trigilia, C., (2005) Sviluppo Locale - Un progetto per l'Italia, , Roma: Ed. Laterza Veiga, J.E., Nascimento de outra ruralidade (2006) Estudos Avançados, 20 (57), pp. 333-353 Veltz, P., (2002) Des lieux et des liens - Politiques du territoire à l'heure de la mondialisation, , Paris : Ed. de l'Aube Wampler, B., Expandindo a accountability através de instituições participativas? Ativistas e reformistas nas municipalidades brasileiras (2005) Desenho institucional e participação política - Experiências no Brasil contemporâneo, pp. 33-62. , Lubambo, Catia COÊLHO, Denílson B. MELO, Marcus A. (Orgs.). Petrópolis: Vozes Weber, M., (1978) Economy and Society: An outline of interpretive Sociology, , Berkeley: University of California Press Woolcock, M., Social capital and economic development: Toward a theoretical synthesis and policy framework (1998) Theory and Society - Renewal and Critique in Social Theory, 27 (2), pp. 151-208 (2005) Equity and Development, , World Bank. Washington D.C.: Oxford University Press (2003) The Triangle of Microfinance: Financial Sustainability, Outreach, and Impact, , ZELLER, Manfred MEYER, Richard (Eds.). John Hopkins University Press Zeller, M., Sharma, M., (1998) Rural Finance and Poverty Alleviation. Food Policy Report, , http://www.ifpri.org, Washington: Internacional Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)