Artículos de revistas
Alfred Marshall And "evolutions" Victorian: Situating Darwin And Spencer Theoretical Foundations Of Thought Marshallian [alfred Marshall E As "evoluções" Vitorianas: Situando Darwin E Spencer Nos Fundamentos Teóricos Do Pensamento Marshalliano]
Registro en:
Nova Economia. , v. 22, n. 3, p. 417 - 450, 2012.
1036351
10.1590/S0103-63512012000300001
2-s2.0-84878441456
Autor
Luz M.R.S.
Fracalanza P.S.
Institución
Resumen
Starting from a comparative study of the theoretical views of Charles Darwin and Herbert Spencer on the processes of change, this paper seeks to understand how the genesis of these ideas about evolution influenced the economic thought of Alfred Marshall. In this sense, we first present how Darwin and Spencer built completely different and irreconcilable approaches to understanding the phenomena of change in complex systems. Subsequently, we try to understand how Marshall absorbed these Victorians elaborations about evolution within his own theoretical construct. Thus, focusing our investigation on Principles (1890) and working with the ideas contained therein about change, progress, equilibrium and representative firm, we seek to show that Marshall followed a code of science characteristically Spencerian, where his approach, often interpreted as "evolutionary," presents no contradiction or incompatibility with a perspective based on neoclassical essentialism. 22 3 417 450 Alvey, J., Some Thought on the Philosophical and Value Assumptions underlying Marshall's Principles of Economics (1987) Macquire University School of Economic and Financial Studies, (317). , Research paper Aspers, P., The Economic Sociology of Alfred Marshall (1999) American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 58 (4), pp. 651-667 Baiardi, D., (2008) Conhecimento, Evolução e Complexidade na Filosofia Sintética de Herbert Spencer, , Dissertação de Mestrado. Faculdade de Filosofia e Ciências Humanas, USP Carneiro, R.L., Structure, Function, and Equilibrium in the Evolutionism of Herbert Spencer (1973) Journal of Anthropological Research, 29 (2), pp. 77-95 Darwin, C., (1859) A Origem das Espécies, , São Paulo: Martin Claret Dawkins, R., (2008) The Oxford Book of Modern Science Writing, , Oxford: Oxford University Press Dennet, D.C., (1995) A Perigosa Ideia de Darwin, , Rio de Janeiro: Rocco Dennet, D.C., The Selfish Gene as a Philosophical Essay (2006) Richard Dawkins: How a Scientist Changed the Way We Think, , In: GRAFFEN, A RIDLEY, M. (2006). Oxford: Oxford University Press Fishburn, G., Natura non facit saltum in Alfred Marshall and Charles Darwin (2004) History of Economics Review, (40), pp. 60-68 Foa, B., Marshall revisited in the Age of DNA (1982) Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 5 (1), pp. 3-16 Foucault, M., (1966) As Palavras e as Coisas: Uma arqueologia das ciências, , São Paulo: Martins Fontes Foss, J.N., The Suppreion of Evolutionary Approaches in Economics: The Case of Marhall and Monopolistic Competition (1991) Methodus, pp. 65-72. , dezembro Foss, J.N., The Biological Analogy and the Theory of the Firm: Marshall and Monopolistic Competition (1994) The Foundations of Evolutionary Economics: 1890-1973, , In: HODGSON, Geoffrey M. (1998) Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Foss, J.N., Thorstein B. Veblen: Precursor of the Competence-Based Approach to the Firm (1996) DRUID Working Paper, 15 (96). , novembro Freeman, D., The Evolutionary Theories of Charles Darwin and Herbert Spencer (1974) Current Anthropology, 15 (3), pp. 211-237 Galbraith, J.K., (1977) A Era da Incerteza, , São Paulo: Pioneira Glassburner, B., Alfred Marshall on Economic History and Historical Development (1955) The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 69 (4), pp. 577-595 Gould, S.J., Introduction (1982) Genetics and the Origin of Species, , In: DOBZHANSKY, Theodosius. (1937). New York: Columbia University Press Guillebaud, C., The Evolution of Marshall's Principles of Economics (1942) The Economic Journal, 52 (208), pp. 330-349 Groenewegen, P., (1995) A Soaring Eagle: Alfred Marshall 1842-1924, , Hants: Edward Elgar Haines, V.A., Is Spencer's Theory an Evolutionary Theory? (1988) The American Journal of Sociology, 93 (5), pp. 1200-1223 Haines, V.A., Spencer's Philosophy of Science (1992) The British Journal of Sociology, 43 (2), pp. 155-172 Hammond, J., Alfred Marshall's Methodology (1991) Methodus, pp. 95-101. , junho Hiskes, R.P., Spencer and the Liberal Idea of Community (1983) The Review of Politics, 45 (4), pp. 595-609 Hodgson, G., The Mecca of Alfred Marshall (1993) Economic Journal, 103, pp. 406-415 Hodgson, G., Introduction (1998) The Foundations of Evolutionary Economics: 1890-1973, , In: HODGSON, Geoffrey M. (1998) Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Hodgson, G., How Can Evolutionary Economics Evolve? (2001) Evolutionary Controversies in Economics, , In: ARUKA, Y. (2001). New York: Springer Hodgson, G., Darwinism, Causality and the Social Sciences (2004) Journal of Economic Methodology, 11 (2), pp. 175-194. , junho Huxley, J., Darwin (1940) Biblioteca do Pensamento Vivo, , In: São Paulo: Martins Editora Jablonka, E., Lamb, M.J., (2005) Evolution in Four Dimensions, , Cambridge: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press Keynes, J.M., Alfred Marshall, 1842-1924 (1924) The Economic Journal, 34 (135), pp. 311-372 la Vergata, A., Herbert Spencer: Biology, Sociology, and Cosmic Evolution (1995) The Foundations of Evolutionary Economics: 1890-1973, , In: HODGSON, G M (1998) Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Leakey, R., Introdução (2007) A Origem das Espécies, , In: DARWIN, Charles. (1859). São Paulo: Martin Claret Leão, I.C., Notas Sobre Marx, Darwin e o Progresso (2001) Economia e Sociedade, (16), pp. 141-145 Lévi-Strauss, C.C., (1962) O Pensamento Selvagem. São Paulo: Papirus Levine, A., Marshall's Principle and the "Biological Viewpoint": A Reconsideration (1983) Manchester School of Economics and Social Studies, 51 (3), pp. 276-293 Loasby, B., Marshall's Economics of Progress (1986) Journal of Economic Studies, 13 (5), pp. 16-26 Loasby, B., Firms, Markets, and the Principle of Continuity (1990) Centenary Essays on Alfred Marshall, , In: WHITAKER, J. (1990). (Org.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Luz, M.R.S., Fracalanza, P.S., Da Te(le)ologia ao Evolucionário: O legado essencialista e a possibilidade darwiniana de teorização econômica (2010) Anais, , In: Anpec, 38, 2010, Salvador. Salvador Marshall, A., The Present Position of Economics (1885) Memorials of Alfred Marshall, , In: PIGOU, A. C. (1925). Londres: Macmillan Marshall, A., (1890) Princípios de Economia, , São Paulo: Abril Cultural Marshall, A., Mechanical and Biological Analogies in Economics (1898) Memorials of Alfred Marshall, , In: PIGOU, A. C.(1925). Londres: Macmillan Mayr, E., (1982) The Growth of Biological Thought, , Cambridge: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press Mayr, E., Darwin's Influence on Modern Thought (2000) Scientific American, pp. 79-83. , julho Mayr, E., (2006) Uma Ampla Discussão. Charles Darwin e a Gênese do Moderno Pensamento Evolucionista, , Ribeirão Preto: FUNPEC Editora Moss, L., Biological Theory and Technological Entrepreneurship in Marshall's Writings (1982) Eastern Economic Journal, 8 (1), pp. 3-13 Moss, L., Evolutionary Change and Marshall's Abandoned Second Volume (1990) Economie Appliquée, 43 (1), pp. 85-98 Nelson, R., Recent Evolutionary Theorizing About Economic Change (1995) Journal of Economic Literature, 1 (33), pp. 48-90. , março Nelson, R., Winter, S.G., (1982) Uma Teoria Evolucionária da Mudança Econômica, , Campinas: Editora Unicamp Parsons, T., Economics and Sociology: Marshall in Relation to the Thought of his Time (1932) The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 46 (2), pp. 316-347 Perrin, R.G., Herbert Spencer's Theories of Social Evolution (1976) The American Journal of Sociology, 81 (6), pp. 1339-1359 Pigou, A.C., An Analysis of Supply (1928) Economic Journal, (38), pp. 238-257 Popper, K., (1950) A Sociedade Aberta e Seus Inimigos, , Belo Horizonte: Livraria Itatiaia Editora Ltda Reisman, D., (1987) Alfred Marshall, progress and politics, , Londres: MacMillan Screpanti, E., Zamagni, S., (2005) An Outline of the History of Economic Thought, , New York: Oxford University Press Sober, E., Evolution, Population Thinking and Essentialism (1980) Philosophy of Science, 47 (3), pp. 350-383 Spencer, H., (1851) Social Statics, , London: Routledge Spencer, H., (1857) Do Progresso: Suas Leis e Suas Causas, , Lisboa: Inquerito Spencer, H., (1862) First Principles, , London: Routledge Staveley, R., Alvey, J., The Philosophical Assumptions Underlying Marshall's Economics (1988) Alfred Marshall Critical Assessments, , In: WOOD, J.(1988). London: Routledge Taylor, M., Introduction (1996) Herbert Spencer: Contemporary Assessments, , In: TAYLOR, M. (1996). London: Routledge Taylor, M., Introduction (1996) First Principles, , In: SPENCER, H. (1862). London: Routledge Thomas, B., Alfred Marshall on Economic Biology (1991) Review of Political Economy, 3 (1), pp. 1-14 Veblen, T., Why is Economics not an Evolutionary Science? (1898) The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 12, pp. 373-397. , julho Veblen, T., (1904) Teoria da Empresa Industrial, , São Paulo: Editora Globo Veblen, T., The Place of Science in Modern Civilization (1906) The American Journal of Sociology, 11 (5), pp. 585-609. , março Whitaker, J., What Happened to the Second Volume of the Principles? (1990) Centenary Essays on Alfred Marshall, , In: WHITAKER, J.(1990). (Org.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Winter, S.G., Survival, Selection and Inheritance in Evolutionary Theories of Organization (1990) Organizational Evolution: New Directions, , In: STING, J.(Org.). Londres: Sage Yamamoto, K., Marshall's Theory of Organic Growth (Draft) (2008) University of Tokyo Young Scholars' Seminar, , março